Keyboard shortcuts

Press or to navigate between chapters

Press S or / to search in the book

Press ? to show this help

Press Esc to hide this help

Merging the final groups

For example, consider these two graphs, which are almost identical except that in the first, w6 targets shard D and in the second in targets B. In the second graph, w6 has been placed in its own group rather than merging it into the [w1] group, because according to the above discussion we should place w6 in a group whose depth is at least 1.

Shard │
      │        ┌───────────┐
    A │        │ w2     w3 │
      │        └/─────────\┘
      │        /           \
      │   ┌───/┐            \
    B │   │ w1 │             \
      │   └────┘              \
      │                        \
      │   ┌────┐               ┌\───┐
    C │   │ w5 │               │ w4 │
      │   └───\┘               └────┘
      │        \
      │        ┌\───┐
    D │        │ w6 │
      │        └────┘

Shard │
      │        ┌───────────┐
    A │        │ w2     w3 │
      │        └/─────────\┘
      │        /           \
      │   ┌───/┐    ┌────┐  \
    B │   │ w1 │    │ w6 │   \
      │   └────┘    └/───┘    \
      │             /          \
      │   ┌────┐   /           ┌\───┐
    C │   │ w5 ───'            │ w4 │
      │   └────┘               └────┘

In both these graphs, the [w5] and [w4] groups can be merged at the cost of increasing D from three to four. In the second graph it is possible to instead merge the [w1] and [w6] groups, which also increases D to four. That is, we could end up with either of these graphs after performing group merging on the second graph:

Shard │
      │        ┌───────────┐
    A │        │ w2     w3 │
      │        └/─────────\┘
      │        /           \
      │   ┌───/┐            \              ┌────┐
    B │   │ w1 │             \             │ w6 │
      │   └────┘              \            └/───┘
      │                        \           /
      │                        ┌\─────────/┐
    C │                        │ w4     w5 │
      │                        └───────────┘

Shard │
      │                     ┌───────────┐
    A │                     │ w2     w3 │
      │                     └/─────────\┘
      │                     /           \
      │        ┌───────────/┐            \
    B │        │ w6      w1 │             \
      │        └/───────────┘              \
      │        /                            \
      │   ┌───/┐                            ┌\───┐
    C │   │ w5 │                            │ w4 │
      │   └────┘                            └────┘

There’s no reason to prefer either of these as they have the same N and D values. What’s important to note is that the decision to merge [w1] and [w6], or to merge [w4] and [w5] are mutually exclusive; once one of these merges has been done, the other is illegal without violating causality.